Book Review: Dancing with Ana by Nicole Barker
Posted by in Young Adult
Dancing with Ana by Nicole Barker
Dancing with Ana is a young adult novel about a girl in high school who decide she is overweight and needs to go on a diet. Immediately she begins starving herself. There is also a subplot about a friend of hers that has an issue with her mother and is afraid of the ocean.
Now, I’m not really an expert on eating disorders or abusive parents but it all seemed a little bit too easy and wrapped up a little too nicely at the end. I found the character development was shallow and the characters unrealistic. I realize that I am not the target audience for this novel but I still had a hard time making myself finish it.
The book dealt with a serious issue (two, if you count the abusive mother subplot) but it was just so cheesy that it was hard to take seriously. It just seemed a little too easy for Beth (the main character) to decide that she was ok with the way her body looked. This book really had potential to be something more but in my opinion it missed the boat. I also found the writing style to be off-putting. I can’t really put my finger on what bothered my about it, but it was just a low level read. Not simple and eloquent, just simple…
Anyway, I really didn’t enjoy this book but I do have one good thing to say about it. For a book with obviously such a low publishing budget, I was amazed at the lack of spelling and grammatical errors. I’ve read books with huge promotional budgets from major publishers with more errors than this book had. Kudos to the editor!
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 You can leave a response, or trackback.
Thanks for checking out my Dancing with Ana rewiew
I totally agree with you, and I really think if the book had been longer, Barker could have delved deeper into the main character and the sub-plots. I really felt cheated by the too-good-to-be-true “happy ending.” I was excited to read it, but in the end, comepletely underwhelmed.
I agree. The book was just scratching the surface. More time would have meant more character and plot development.
I have to disagree with you guys, maybe to you it just scratched the surface and I see where you’re coming from but to me the book went deeper and uncovered a group of people who are very close to me- the ones with the greatest problems that everyone overlooks. While it is a short book I find it hit everything that a teenage girl- like me- deals with.
-the book was meant for teenage girls nowadays-
While you may need more character developement when your my age you recognize the characters so quickly that they are clearly real people you know. It gave just enough about the characters that you can imagine them as your friends
Pingback: Shouting Gorilla Book Blog » Blog Archive » Dancing with Ana by Nicole Barker